Investor Type

Tell us once and we'll remember.

I'm an...

Don't worry, you can always change this selection using the icons at the top left of the site.
Institutional Investor Advisor Individual Investor


Appreciation Strategy

Fourth Quarter 2018

Key Takeaways
  • Revised expectations for forward U.S. economic growth created volatility across the financial markets.
  • Large capitalization technology stocks looked expensive and crowded to us during the third quarter, but recent declines and still healthy fundamentals have created attractive entry points.
  • During the fourth quarter we saw some intriguing opportunities, reduced cash levels in our portfolio and added several new names.
Market Overview and Outlook

The U.S. stock market experienced a difficult fourth quarter, falling -13.5%, and had its first down year since 2008 with a total return of -4.4%. The market came within a hair of technically being labeled a bear market (down 20% from the peak) before bouncing significantly after Christmas. Volatility, as measured by the VIX index, increased from near historical lows in 2017 to about average in 2018. Investors were dealing with various issues in 2018, including fears of a trade war with China, turmoil in the White House, weakness in international economic numbers and Federal Reserve policy that is perhaps more backward looking.

Revised expectations for forward U.S. economic growth created volatility across the financial markets. Yields on the 10-year U.S. Treasury fell from a high of 3.23% on November 8 to a low of 2.68% at year-end. The short-end of the yield curve inverted the last week of 2018 and again the first week of 2019. The 2-year to 10-year Treasury spread narrowed to only 12 basis points in early December, the tightest since 2008. An inverted yield curve has historically proved to be a reasonably good predictor of recessions. Oil prices peaked north of $75 in early October but cratered to the mid-$40s by year-end. Coming into the fourth quarter, oil markets had been anticipating shortages caused by new Iranian sanctions. Instead, the sanctions had little impact and weaker global economic results reduced demand expectations. The U.S. dollar increased from 1.16 Euros to 1.145 during the quarter, making a new high for the year but still trading within a narrow range.

The best performers in the fourth quarter were low-risk or defensive stocks. The strongest groups were the utilities, consumer staples and health care sectors, while the cyclical energy, materials, industrials and consumer discretionary lagged. For the year, the defensive utilities and health care sectors did well, but strong earnings growth enabled consumer discretionary and technology stocks to report gains as well. Large capitalization stocks significantly outperformed small, while highly leveraged companies and those with credit problems were among the weakest stocks in the market.

U.S. economic news started the quarter very strong but ended more mixed. While the U.S. consumer did well, manufacturing experienced some softness to close out 2018. Retail sales were outstanding, posting one of the best Christmas seasons in years. Car sales were steady above 17 million (seasonally adjusted annual rate), although results were boosted by high fleet sales. Housing slowed slightly but continued to grow. Unemployment claims bottomed for the cycle in September at 205,000 before rising to 231,000 by December — still a very low number. Job creation was terrific in December at 312,000 and average hourly wage growth picked up to 3.2%. Employment is the best single indicator of the health of the U.S. economy but tends to lag at the onset of a recession.


"We need to be mindful of credit problems and Federal Reserve policy."


The market was very concerned about the combined impact of Chinese trade friction, international slowing and Federal Reserve policy on the manufacturing economy. The December ISM fell sharply from 59.3 to 54.1 — still indicative of a growing economy, but the third-sharpest decline in the indicator in 20 years. We are most likely witnessing a growth slowdown from red hot conditions last summer, but we need to be mindful of credit problems and Federal Reserve policy. The BAA spread, a key indicator of credit stress, decisively broke out during the fourth quarter and is now above the average for the business cycle. Real interest rates of just above zero are not likely to retard the economy per se, but the narrow yield curve must be watched. The current Federal Reserve balance sheet reduction of $50 billion per month is a clear headwind, as is the decline in the money supply we saw in 2018.

Large capitalization technology stocks looked expensive and crowded to us during the third quarter, but recent declines and still healthy fundamentals have created attractive entry points. The big cap pharmaceutical stocks looked very interesting six months ago. Even after their strong fourth-quarter performance, a couple of the names still look intriguing but overall the group looks fairly valued to us. We would continue to avoid the utilities, which sell at record relative valuations despite poor revenue outlooks and deteriorating allowed returns. We are generally wary of the materials sector but are interested in companies that benefit from lower raw material costs.

We were quite nervous about the market a quarter ago, but at least from a valuation standpoint we feel better now. During the fourth quarter we saw some intriguing opportunities, reduced cash levels in our portfolio and added several new names. That said, we continue to feel that a conservative stance is most appropriate at this time. We are late in the economic cycle. Growth in 2019 will be significantly lower than last year even if the Federal Reserve is able to engineer a soft landing. The Appreciation strategy of owning large, high-quality stocks is well-suited for today’s market, offering upside participation if the economy remains robust and preserving capital should a trade war erupt or should the Fed’s tightening result in an inverted yield curve.

Portfolio Highlights

The ClearBridge Appreciation Strategy had a negative return during the fourth quarter of 2018, outperforming the Strategy’s S&P 500 Index benchmark.

On an absolute basis, the Strategy had gains in three sectors in which it was invested during the quarter (out of 11 sectors total). The main contributors to the Strategy’s performance were the real estate, consumer staples and utilities sectors. The main detractors were the IT and financials sectors.

In relative terms, the Strategy outperformed its benchmark impacted by stock selection and sector allocation. In particular, stock selection in the communication services, financials, health care and consumer staples sectors added the most to relative performance. The Strategy’s cash position also helped. Conversely, an underweight to the utilities sector dragged on relative performance during the quarter.

On an individual stock basis, the biggest contributors to absolute returns during the quarter included positions in Merck, American Tower, Procter & Gamble, CME Group and Aetna. The greatest detractors from absolute returns were positions in Apple, Microsoft, Raytheon, Home Depot and JPMorgan Chase.

During the quarter, we established positions in, W.W. Grainger, CVS, and We closed positions in Ameren, Broadcom, Fastenal and Citigroup. Our shares of Aetna were converted to shares of CVS following CVS’s acquisition of Aetna and were retained.

Scott Glasser

Co-Chief Investment Officer, Portfolio Manager
29 Years experience
27 Years at ClearBridge

Michael Kagan

Portfolio Manager
35 Years experience
26 Years at ClearBridge

Related Perspectives

  • Appreciation Strategy
    1Q20 Commentary: What makes a company robust in a slowdown are the same when demand stops — a strong balance sheet and a dominant franchise.
  • Appreciation Strategy
    4Q19 Commentary: Markets will be more dependent on a rebound in earnings to drive the next leg of market returns.
  • ClearBridge Economic & Market Outlook for 2020
    PMs Albert Grosman and Michael Kagan join Jeff Schulze to discuss positioning for the year ahead.
  • AssetTV Global Market Outlook for 2020
    A ClearBridge panel shares their views on recession and geopolitical risks and where they see opportunities as active managers in the year ahead.
  • Appreciation Strategy Update
    PM Michael Kagan weighs recession risks and details how the defensive-led rally favored the Appreciation Strategy's approach in the third quarter.

Related Blog Posts

  • All opinions and data included in this commentary are as of December 31, 2018, and are subject to change. The opinions and views expressed herein are of the portfolio management team named above and may differ from other managers, or the firm as a whole, and are not intended to be a forecast of future events, a guarantee of future results or investment advice. This information should not be used as the sole basis to make any investment decision. The statistics have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but the accuracy and completeness of this information cannot be guaranteed. Neither ClearBridge nor its information providers are responsible for any damages or losses arising from any use of this information.

  • Performance source: Internal. Benchmark source: Standard & Poor’s.
  • Past performance is no guarantee of future results.